the songs on coupled with are of much better quality than...

Albums, singles, songs and general Wildhearts banter
Forum rules
Divvn't be a twat

the songs on coupled with are of much better quality than...

Postby pete gusher » 8th May 07, 12:30

the songs on must be destroyed.


discuss.
pete gusher
 
Posts: 194
Joined: 17th Feb 06, 19:59
Location: bradford / leeds

Re: the songs on coupled with are of much better quality tha

Postby Keith Richard » 8th May 07, 13:08

pete gusher wrote:the songs on must be destroyed.


discuss.


Are you a school teacher?...Is this an exam question?

Here's my question to you...define "quality", also, how does one quantify "much better"?
"Some Days Just Fucking Suck"
Keith Richard
 
Posts: 746
Joined: 13th Feb 06, 18:44
Location: Singapore

Postby fluffygrue » 8th May 07, 13:17

Nah, don't agree. WH Must Be Destroyed is a superb album. Coupled With has some gems, but doesn't compare.
fluffygrue
 
Posts: 528
Joined: 23rd Feb 06, 15:47
Location: Manchester, UK

Re: the songs on coupled with are of much better quality tha

Postby geordierussell » 8th May 07, 13:21

pete gusher wrote:the songs on must be destroyed.


discuss.


NO
geordierussell
 
Posts: 1231
Joined: 9th Mar 06, 18:59
Location: chesterfield

Postby fluffygrue » 8th May 07, 13:25

Hm, you're in Bradford. Is it raining as much over there?

I suspect my dog's not getting a walk today.
fluffygrue
 
Posts: 528
Joined: 23rd Feb 06, 15:47
Location: Manchester, UK

Postby pete gusher » 8th May 07, 13:26

ive just been listening to it this morning, and i think its a much better album (even tho its a bit of a cut and paste album) than must be destroyed

cmon someone must agree
pete gusher
 
Posts: 194
Joined: 17th Feb 06, 19:59
Location: bradford / leeds

Postby markE » 8th May 07, 13:30

i love em both :D
why do i have to ignore you to get your attention?
markE
 
Posts: 764
Joined: 18th May 06, 13:53

Postby pete gusher » 8th May 07, 13:31

fluffygrue wrote:Hm, you're in Bradford. Is it raining as much over there?

I suspect my dog's not getting a walk today.


nah its just spitting a bit
i suggest throwing a stick up the stairs for him to fetch repetedly, until hes too fucked to want a walk anyway
pete gusher
 
Posts: 194
Joined: 17th Feb 06, 19:59
Location: bradford / leeds

Postby fluffygrue » 8th May 07, 13:33

pete gusher wrote:
fluffygrue wrote:Hm, you're in Bradford. Is it raining as much over there? I suspect my dog's not getting a walk today.


nah its just spitting a bit
i suggest throwing a stick up the stairs for him to fetch repetedly, until hes too fucked to want a walk anyway


Yeah, that's the plan. :P

I should probably stop reading forums and do something productive, too.. Hm.
fluffygrue
 
Posts: 528
Joined: 23rd Feb 06, 15:47
Location: Manchester, UK

Postby Ross » 8th May 07, 13:42

Coupled With has a couple of gems (OCD, Action Panzer, Bang, LTD) a couple of real stinkers (If I Decide, Move On, Let's Go, Cheers) and the rest is ok if not spectacular... Must be Destroyed hangs together well, but has a few fillers as well. It's a good album, not great. Possibly a couple of the tunes on Coupled With could have been album tracks, but also there are tracks on Must Be... which are poor in comparison to the rest.

Open verdict, they're all a product of the same time, and some harsh editing could have led to a much better album... But then we wouldn't be able to say the Wildhearts B-sides are better than the A-sides would we?
Image
Ross
 
Posts: 407
Joined: 1st Mar 06, 17:28
Location: Leicester UK

Postby Piedude » 8th May 07, 13:46

I think its better in places, about the same in other places but while theres no songs on Must Be Destroyed I dont like, Im not a fan of "If I decide"...Id say its equal, on the basis that its about twice as long...
Piedude
 
Posts: 360
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 14:58
Location: Swansea

Postby pete gusher » 8th May 07, 14:00

Ross wrote:Coupled With has a couple of gems (OCD, Action Panzer, Bang, LTD) a couple of real stinkers (If I Decide, Move On, Let's Go, Cheers) and the rest is ok if not spectacular... Must be Destroyed hangs together well, but has a few fillers as well. It's a good album, not great. Possibly a couple of the tunes on Coupled With could have been album tracks, but also there are tracks on Must Be... which are poor in comparison to the rest.

Open verdict, they're all a product of the same time, and some harsh editing could have led to a much better album... But then we wouldn't be able to say the Wildhearts B-sides are better than the A-sides would we?


you think move on is a stinker?? really???
i think that song is almost classic wildhearts!
pete gusher
 
Posts: 194
Joined: 17th Feb 06, 19:59
Location: bradford / leeds

Postby Ross » 8th May 07, 14:09

I like the intro, that's about it... The verses are just pop-rock by numbers... It just is a weak weak track...

But Let's Go is the worst track... The chorus bears no relation to the rest of the song and has no discernible tune.
Image
Ross
 
Posts: 407
Joined: 1st Mar 06, 17:28
Location: Leicester UK

Postby MikeH » 8th May 07, 14:15

pete gusher wrote:
Ross wrote:Coupled With has a couple of gems (OCD, Action Panzer, Bang, LTD) a couple of real stinkers (If I Decide, Move On, Let's Go, Cheers) and the rest is ok if not spectacular... Must be Destroyed hangs together well, but has a few fillers as well. It's a good album, not great. Possibly a couple of the tunes on Coupled With could have been album tracks, but also there are tracks on Must Be... which are poor in comparison to the rest.

Open verdict, they're all a product of the same time, and some harsh editing could have led to a much better album... But then we wouldn't be able to say the Wildhearts B-sides are better than the A-sides would we?


you think move on is a stinker?? really???
i think that song is almost classic wildhearts!


Agreement - Off with his head!
MikeH
 
Posts: 36
Joined: 4th Dec 06, 02:05
Location: Perth, Scotland

Postby Lord Iffy Boatrace » 8th May 07, 14:22

i dont see much difference between them. i think they are both great. my faves are songs like Lake of piss, ocd, 630 onwards etc. i dont know why some of u guys dont like it! twmbd is awesome as well. both are much better than endless nameless.
Lord Iffy Boatrace
 
Posts: 75
Joined: 20th Feb 06, 13:49
Location: East Kilbride, Scotland

Next

Return to Wildhearts Music and General Chat

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests

cron