The Offspring - Rise and Fall, Rage and Grace (My Review)

Off-topic chat. Items cannot be returned without a ticket.

The Offspring - Rise and Fall, Rage and Grace (My Review)

Postby nuno75 » 13th Jun 08, 13:34

01 - Half-Truism

Starts off light and pretty... jumps to vocal right away though. First verse is pretty generic. Peppy by most standards, but a little sluggish and plain for The Offspring. Then the chorus comes in. Very melodic and slower. It sounds familiar, but I can't quite put my finger on what it reminds me of. Regardless, I'm liking it since the chorus came in. Yeah, when the verse jumps back in, the tempo change is more of a switchup and is therefore cooler. Predictably into the bridge after the second chorus. Back to the pretty intro... with some effects-laden vocals crooning along on top. All in all, I'd say this was a good song. Uncharacteristic for this band, but still pretty good.

02 - Trust In You

Now, here's The Offspring we've all come to expect. Fast and almost identical to a dozen other Offspring songs... but we love 'em anyway. As such, there's not really much I can say about this one other than it's one of those songs they throw together to go in between all the other songs. There's some kind of weird synth off in the distance something... so I guess that sets it apart it a little. Cool little guitar thing in the bridge, but it was very short. And now we're coming to the end. Yup. It's an Offspring song. That's all.

03 - You're Gonna Go Far, Kid

Starts off with kind of a disco kind of beat and start/stop chords while dude's singing about something or other. Catchy so far. Now, the song kicks in... except the drums stay in the disco thing which doesn't quite fit... still catchy. I think I heard the F-word somewhere in there. Now the pre-chorus... oh cool. Weird guitar effects making it kind of cosmic and spooky sounding. Still catchy. Now it kicks in full blast for a bit for the chorus and jumps back to the intro bit for the second verse. The chorus is still catchy but it loses something after the verse and pre-chorus. Harmonizing guitars for the solo and then a "break it down" section with just drums and bass and the sing along chorus, "Dance Fucker Dance". This one was pretty cool.

04 - Hammerhead

I heard this one a week or two ago and recall not being impressed. It's the first single. Starts off with a dark clean guitar... and then some intermittent distortion guitars building up to introduce us to the main riff, which then comes in full blast, but only briefly... then right into the verse. One of those deals with it jumps to a chord and rides there for a while with the guy singing over and then kind of "lands" on the main riff again in between lines. Okay, this is better than I remember. Bad Religion-esque background vocals during the chorus just kind of going "whoahhhhh" behind the regular vocals. Second verse... same as the first... pre-chorus, chorus... I'm waiting for the bridge, I remember a pretty big change happening... okay... here it comes... fade out on the guitars, bass playing a fancy riff... ohhh.. okay... now I remember. It's a blatant rip-off of the riff to The Kinks' All Day and All of the Night. At least he's got a different vocal melody. Now it builds up, still on the bridge-riff... "woo hoo!" high falsetto shout-outs in the background. Stones-ishness. Cool. Never went back to the main song after the bridge. That's weird but cool.

05 - A Lot Like Me

Piano intro. Reminds me of Evanescance. Now it's just and drums and the vocals start. Dude's singing very low... it might not even be him. Now the piano comes back in and the main singer comes in to accompany the other guy (or himself?) only an octave higher. Chorus is here now.... it's bigger and louder, but still slow. Now it's reminding me of Angels and Airwaves. This is, so far, the least Offspring-sounding Offspring song I've ever heard. It's not bad, just weird for this band. I guess it's cool that they're stretching their musical legs a little. It's not quite a ballad, but it's as close as I've heard them get before.

06 - Takes Me Nowhere

Again with the jumping right into the vocals first thing. This one is him singing along with one guitar and drums. Good peppy beat, good melody. I like it already. It gets a little generic once everything kicks in but it's still okay. Again, I'm reminded a little of Bad Religion. There's something a little spicy about the melody in the verse that has caught my ear now. The chorus is a dual vocal deal, with the main guy singing a long drawn out line with the other guys (actually just a bunch of the main guy) singing shorter other stuff. I missed the pre-chorus the first time through and I'd like to note that I now notice some "ahhh ahhh" harmony stuff in the background. The bridge is mostly just variations on the main chord progression. Nothing special there. Back into the chorus... and out. This one was okay... but by the time it was all said and done it did leave me slightly wanting.

07 - Kristi, Are You Doing Okay?

Uh oh... acoustic guitar intro. Same progression as Green Day's "Good Riddence"... but the progression changes for the verse, so that's good. This guy sounds pretty nasal when he's trying to sing pretty. So far just one guy singing and one acoustic guitar (actually two, but they're both panned opposite each other and playing the same thing). I've got my Zippo in the air and I'm waving it like I just don't care. Ten bucks says they'll throw this one out as a single and I'm not even to the chorus yet. Okay... drums and light electric guitars for the chorus. Second verse goes back to acoustic, but the drums are there now, and the electrics come in gradually. This is still definitely a ballad. I could see people slow dancing to this with no strain on my imagination at all. Anyway... the melody is good. Since I'm not your stereotypical ballad-hater, this isn't terrible for me... but I do feel strangely let down hearing it from these guys. Still... it feels very personal to me and I like that a lot. I'm gonna call this a very good song, though I know most people will hate it strictly for being a slow and pretty song.

08 - Nothingtown

Swing beat. Pretty snappy. Chord progression that's been used a million times before... but that's okay. This is pretty cool so far. There's those fancy harmonies humming along in the background again. Now it's starting to feel a little "cute" on the musical end of things... which has been kind of an ugly trend with this band since they made a splash on the radio. Well... at least it's only the music and the lyrics aren't any stupid bullshit about "her legs all up in the air". In fact, although the lyrics are typical relationship-fodder, they still seem to be well put together and not terribly literal. This one's okay but I can see myself getting sick of it pretty quick. Too catchy.

09 - Stuff Is Messed Up

More swing beat. Starts with a rumbly toms beat and what sounds like exhaling in rhythm with the drums. It's not as dumb as it sounds though. Comes across a little AC/DC-ish. Actually... now the lyrics are coming in and it's still something I could easily imagine Bon Scott singing. Okay... they've clearly edited the song title, because the chorus is "Shit Is Fucked Up". Even after the chorus, I still AC/DC. He's not singing quite so tight on the melody as he usually does here... more kind of just saying and yelling stuff generally in the area of the right key. That's cool because it puts a lot of feeling into it that's been missing on this album so far. There's some super-fast lyrics in the bridge, though I didn't really pay attention to what they were. It sounded cool though, Then back to the chorus, "La la la la la... you know it's all about the dream... la la la la la the ends justify the means"... This was very. My favorite from this album by a long shot.

10 - Fix You

More soft pretty guitar... soft pretty singing... soft pretty synth off to the one side. As it carries on I hear/feel a very faint bass drum, thump-thump, thump-thump... exactly like the one at toward the beginning of Green Day's "Wake Me When September Ends". In fact... so far, this song is put together pretty much just like that one. Anyway... despite all that, it's got a nice melody and a pleasant riff... and is really sounding like another full-on ballad. I bet this one kicks in shortly and gets really "big" and explosive sounding without really speeding up any... just like the Green Day song. Okay... where was I? Okay... now there's piano too. Still pretty. Good, so far for what it is. More La-la-la's. Uh oh... second verse... I hear snares tapping... louder louder... and... Oh wait... it's bigger, but not quite the explosion I was expecting. Out of the second chorus... got some Bono-esque falsetto stuff going on. Man... you guys are gonna fucking HATE this shit. Ballad #2.

Okay... so it never quite "exploded"... but I was close. I liked it... but you won't.

11 - Let's Hear It For Rock Bottom

Starts off peppy... not fast, but peppy and punky... then drops into a ska thing with chinky chinky guitars and fancy hi-hat work. Lyrics come in... they're kind of dark... reminds me of "Message In A Bottle" somehow. Into the chorus it goes back to the intro riff... not particularly remarkable... but less dark and happier... and yet still somehow tropical despite it being all power chords. Kind of cool bridge... "ohhhh ohhhhhhhhh" Again reminding me of The Police. Then back into the chorus a bunch of times and fading out. I like this one. It wasn't great, but it was good.

12 - Rise And Fall

Starts off with a guitar riff. It sounds very "studio"... like the mic was set across the room from the amp. Nice touch, but Green Day did that too. Anyway... once it all gets going it's pretty cool. Still closer to Green Day than anything Offspring has done before. Actually... remove the vocals and this could be a Green Day song. Lucky for them I like Green Day too, and don't mind similarities between bands. That being said... this one was just okay. Something weird about the vocals vs. the riff didn't quite go together right and I couldn't quite catch a groove.

13 - O.C. Life

This starts off sounding like some old-school punk. It's not terribly fast or anything. I'm feeling a little Agent Orange here. It sounds like an old song... it's very basic, and a little dark. This is good. I like the step backwards into a more "real" punk rock sound.




All in all I'm gonna give this one a 5.5. Only one song on it that I would say is "really good", and only one or two I would say "meh" too. Nothing particularly bad, but about 90% just so-so.

For me, The Offspring came into themselves with the album Smash... and continued that with Ixnay on the Hombre and, to an extent, Americana... but then they got a little full of themselves and got a little too cute and a little too funny. Before, the impression they gave was that they were a real punk band who occasionally did poppy sounding stuff almost to make fun of the actual poppy stuff. With Splinter and Conspiracy of One, they suddenly didn't seem like they were making fun of anyone anymore. That's just who they wanted to be. Plus I got the distinct feeling they had hit the wall and were trying really really hard to keep the ball rolling... and in vain.

So how does this album fit with all of that? I'd say it's a small step in the right direction. There's very little, if any, actual comedy here... and that's a BIG plus... but again... there was only one "classic"-Offspring sounding song here... and there are two, bordering on three, actual ballads. On the other hand, where their lyrics had begun to get very literal at times, this album's lyrics struck me as notably more inspired and less forced. It seems to me like there were some hard decisions made about the direction of the band before this was recorded... and while it did make a difference, it probably won't be enough of one to make up for the damage they've done to themselves. Yeah... they're still gonna come across as more candy-ass than bad-ass... but even if they've taken a step more in the direction of Green Day, at least it's a step away from Weird Al. At the same time, as always, it's important to remember that these guys are maturing as both musicians and as people... and that can change a lot of stuff too.

For me this album is good enough to keep me hanging on and hoping they straighten up for the next one... but it's not gonna achieve the "classic" status that Smash and Americana have for me.
nuno75
 
Posts: 528
Joined: 15th May 07, 22:48

Postby spoon_of_grimbo » 14th Jun 08, 02:17

i listened to the stream of this, and i like it. as they're the band who got me into rock music in general, i'll always have a soft spot for them anyway. although buying this album comes second priority to getting Less Than Jake's new one ("GNV FLA"). i'm listening to the leak now, and it's fucking awesome, the best thing they've done in at least 6 years!
IF THERE'S A SOUND YOU PLAY THAT DOESN'T FIT TODAY,
WHY NOT JUST PLAY THE BASTARD ANYWAY?!
Image
spoon_of_grimbo
 
Posts: 915
Joined: 19th Aug 07, 13:56
Location: Boston, UK (Home) / Coventry, UK (Uni)

Postby loz » 20th Jun 08, 18:34

Re. "Hammerhead" - anyone else hearing a bit of "Love U Til I Don't" after the Kinks ripoff, then a bit of the Almighty's "United State Of Apathy"..?

Maybe it's just me... :P
loz
 
Posts: 37
Joined: 9th Mar 06, 19:33
Location: North Shields


Return to The Cloakroom

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests