Time signatures

Off-topic chat. Items cannot be returned without a ticket.

Time signatures

Postby Stuart Brackpool » 22nd Mar 08, 23:07

Could some kind soul explain to me the theory of time signatures? I play the drums, pretty well if I say so myself, but I've no idea what those strange little numbers signify. I know I can play in different and unusual time signatures but it would be nice to know how they work in a theoretical sense. Please illustrate with examples if possible, i.e:

Kashmir by Led Zeppelin is in 6/8, apparently.

The solo in Soundgarden's Black Hole Sun is in 13/8, I believe

AC/DC's entire canon is 4/4, so it is said.

Like I say, playing them is no problem, I'd just like to understand the theory for my own edification.

Many thanks for any help you can give.
Stuart Brackpool
 
Posts: 173
Joined: 8th Jan 07, 17:18
Location: Halesowen

Postby zachary_storm » 23rd Mar 08, 20:51

well im not the greatest theory guy... but here goes... i'll try & put it from as much of a drummers point o view as i can! haha!

the crotchet notes, which are the notes which last for 1 beat outta a bar, make up 4 beats in a bar o 4/4

so therefore 6/4 would contain 6 beat bars

but then you get slightly more complicated ones like 2/4 & 3/4 which by now you should be able to work out??

2/4 - 2 beats to a bar but thats o so similar to 4/4

3/4 - 3 beats in a bar which gives like a swing-feel

and theres 6/4 which is rather tricky

...

then come the really silly time sigs like 6/2 & other such gay time sigs!

which you would use minim notes, or a note which lasts for 2 beats

so that would be 6 beats in a bar... then i get confused & loose track...

but hope what i've said helps! maybe someone wi more knowledge can shed more light on it!

:)
"ONLY THOSE THAT KNOW HOW TO ROCK KNOW WHEN TO ROLL!!!"
zachary_storm
 
Posts: 251
Joined: 15th Dec 07, 21:53
Location: Rochdale, Manchester

Postby Ean » 23rd Mar 08, 21:27

Right, let's have a bash at this...

While I understand this stuff, writing it down without it being completely unintelligible is another thing entirely so I'll borrow from some people who've already done the work...

I don't know what your music theory's like, so to go right back to the beginning you need to read this, as time signatures are all based on note lengths; number of notes in a beat and number of beats in a bar - In the normal course of things, you can ignore note lengths above a Semibreve, as there's not that much call for notes that last more than four crotchet beats (i.e. more than one whole bar of 4/4 time).

Onto time signatures then... start here, then read this one and this one. They're pretty similar, but there are bits and pieces that aren't mentioned in all of them.

To get more complicated, there's this site, and the Wikipedia entry is pretty good, as is the linked entry of Musical works in unusual time signatures.

To bring it back onto examples that aren't necessarily mentioned on those sites...

Skychaser High and Couple Trouble are both in 12/8 (you can hear the 12 hi-hat beats in every bar)
The staccato bit at the end of Sky Babies is in 7/8
There's a bit about 4.25 into Drinking In The Daytime which goes:
8 bars of 7/8
2 x ( 1 bar of 6/8 and 1 bar of 7/8 )
3 x ( 1 bar of 7/8 and 1 bar of 10/8 )


A few comparisons of similar but different sounding signatures...
The intro to Everlone is in 6/8 (as is Metallica's Nothing Else Matters), whereas the middle section from Lake Of Piss is in 6/4 and the chorus from Channel Bop is in 3/4.
Pink Floyd's Money is in 7/4 whereas NIN' March Of The Pigs is in 7/8.

I did know something in 5/4, but I'm buggered if I can remember what it is... :roll:

It's not that easy with Kashmir, the guitar riff was written to give the effect of being in 3/4 as it's three bars of four (rather than four bars of three for traditional 3/4 time), but if you listen to the drums, it's 8 and a half minutes of plodding 4/4. :wink:

Oh, and Black Hole Sun isn't quite that complicated, it's only in 9/8. :D

Any help?
Last edited by Ean on 24th Mar 08, 05:24, edited 1 time in total.
Ean Ü

"I have to go along with all this reclusive genius stuff... she's going to be very upset when she finds out I'm a reclusive wanker."

WH THEMED WH EMOTiCONS? MAiS OUi!!
User avatar
Ean
 
Posts: 3084
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 15:44
Location: Just next to my confuser

Postby spoon_of_grimbo » 24th Mar 08, 03:11

if you want some fun with time signatures, try learning "vicarious" by tool. most of it is in 5/4, which is actually kinda natural feeling to sing/hum along to, but a bastard to actually play. it's got other bits in 4/4, 7/4 and 2/4 (i think those are right anyway).

also the drums in that song can be summed with the term "some real mad shit."
IF THERE'S A SOUND YOU PLAY THAT DOESN'T FIT TODAY,
WHY NOT JUST PLAY THE BASTARD ANYWAY?!
Image
spoon_of_grimbo
 
Posts: 915
Joined: 19th Aug 07, 13:56
Location: Boston, UK (Home) / Coventry, UK (Uni)

Postby Damian » 24th Mar 08, 11:34

Once you've got a grip on all this, put some Cardiacs on. :D
Damian
 
Posts: 1257
Joined: 11th Feb 06, 02:14
Location: Bristol, UK

Postby Stuart Brackpool » 26th Mar 08, 13:26

Thanks for your help. I knew Pink Floyd's Money was in an odd time signature but did you know it changes to a more standard 4/4 during the guitar solo as David Gilmour had trouble playing in that time?

Your advice has been very helpful. As for a Cardiacs selection, I'm thinking Anything I Can't Eat, that one goes everywhere!
Stuart Brackpool
 
Posts: 173
Joined: 8th Jan 07, 17:18
Location: Halesowen

Postby spoon_of_grimbo » 26th Mar 08, 15:43

Stuart Brackpool wrote:Thanks for your help. I knew Pink Floyd's Money was in an odd time signature but did you know it changes to a more standard 4/4 during the guitar solo as David Gilmour had trouble playing in that time?

Your advice has been very helpful. As for a Cardiacs selection, I'm thinking Anything I Can't Eat, that one goes everywhere!


i knew it changed, but i didn't know that was the reason why!

to be fair, i think a change in time-sig always makes a transitional part of a song stand out better, it wouldn't be the same if the whole song was in 7/8.



oh, and btw, another Tool number "lateralus" has a chorus bit where there's three bars, which go 9/8 to 8/8 to 7/8.
IF THERE'S A SOUND YOU PLAY THAT DOESN'T FIT TODAY,
WHY NOT JUST PLAY THE BASTARD ANYWAY?!
Image
spoon_of_grimbo
 
Posts: 915
Joined: 19th Aug 07, 13:56
Location: Boston, UK (Home) / Coventry, UK (Uni)

Postby Ean » 26th Mar 08, 18:24

spoon_of_grimbo wrote:
Stuart Brackpool wrote:Thanks for your help. I knew Pink Floyd's Money was in an odd time signature but did you know it changes to a more standard 4/4 during the guitar solo as David Gilmour had trouble playing in that time?


i knew it changed, but i didn't know that was the reason why!


Didn't seem to mind making the Sax player's life a misery though... :roll:
Ean Ü

"I have to go along with all this reclusive genius stuff... she's going to be very upset when she finds out I'm a reclusive wanker."

WH THEMED WH EMOTiCONS? MAiS OUi!!
User avatar
Ean
 
Posts: 3084
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 15:44
Location: Just next to my confuser

Postby earthvs » 26th Mar 08, 21:38

Stuart Brackpool wrote:I knew Pink Floyd's Money was in an odd time signature but did you know it changes to a more standard 4/4 during the guitar solo as David Gilmour had trouble playing in that time?


I'm pretty certain that the time change was included as a concilliatory gesture from Roger Waters to Nick Mason - Mason, by his own admission, has never been the most technically proficient of drummers, and he struggled to hold the timing down during the recording of Money. So, after having a word with/complaining to Waters, it was agreed that the middle solo section would be altered to 4/4 to give him a break from all the troublesome concentrating.

Whilst on the subject of Floyd members, has anybody else noticed that David Gilmour seems to be continually sucking on a boiled sweet when he plays his guitar solos? I wonder whether it's a minty humbug or a Werther's Original... :?:
Image
"Do you honestly think you can grow wings with those restricting robes?"
earthvs
 
Posts: 54
Joined: 18th Oct 07, 22:13
Location: Shropshire

Postby Andwah » 26th Mar 08, 21:51

One of my favourite 5/4 tunes to play along to is Seven Days by the man they call Sting, quality tune, helped me to understand drum music more with that, another one by the same bloke is I Hung My Head (which the man Cash covered), that's in 7/8 though.

Forget what you like and give them a chance for playing along to, they do of course feature the king who is Vinnie Coliauta on drums, the man who aided the fucking of one Mr Zappa's mind.
Andwah
 
Posts: 190
Joined: 19th Dec 07, 16:41

Postby Ean » 26th Mar 08, 22:06

earthvs wrote:I'm pretty certain that the time change was included as a concilliatory gesture from Roger Waters to Nick Mason...

Nope. I saw the show they quote from, and that's the reason they give.

Whilst on the subject of Floyd members, has anybody else noticed that David Gilmour seems to be continually sucking on a boiled sweet when he plays his guitar solos? I wonder whether it's a minty humbug or a Werther's Original...

He's a rock guitarist, and he's doing it properly - there's a special nerve that runs directly from the left hand to the guitarist's mouth. Did you not see Scott on the recent Acoustibollox tour? :shock:
Ean Ü

"I have to go along with all this reclusive genius stuff... she's going to be very upset when she finds out I'm a reclusive wanker."

WH THEMED WH EMOTiCONS? MAiS OUi!!
User avatar
Ean
 
Posts: 3084
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 15:44
Location: Just next to my confuser

Postby earthvs » 26th Mar 08, 22:23

I think I read the Nick Mason theory in Classic Rock once. Or maybe I dreamed it.

Nick Mason does admit he's a shite drummer though, in his Floyd biography Inside Out.
Image
"Do you honestly think you can grow wings with those restricting robes?"
earthvs
 
Posts: 54
Joined: 18th Oct 07, 22:13
Location: Shropshire

Postby Ean » 26th Mar 08, 22:33

earthvs wrote:I think I read the Nick Mason theory in Classic Rock once. Or maybe I dreamed it.

Nick Mason does admit he's a shite drummer though, in his Floyd biography Inside Out.

Ah, Muso hacks - not known for the fabrication of facts... :roll:

Did Mason not mention the Money thing in his bio?
Ean Ü

"I have to go along with all this reclusive genius stuff... she's going to be very upset when she finds out I'm a reclusive wanker."

WH THEMED WH EMOTiCONS? MAiS OUi!!
User avatar
Ean
 
Posts: 3084
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 15:44
Location: Just next to my confuser

Postby earthvs » 26th Mar 08, 22:43

Curiously, no.

I know i've read the questionable theory I posted somewhere, so i've just gone through the book, stopping at even vague references to the recording of Dark Side..., but he doesn't mention anything about Money beyond all the band members doing strange things with tape loops , string, coins and paper to achieve the sound effects.

But I suppose, if he's already admitted that basically, he's not actually that good with his instrument :wink: he'd be loathe to confess to further inadequacy.
Image
"Do you honestly think you can grow wings with those restricting robes?"
earthvs
 
Posts: 54
Joined: 18th Oct 07, 22:13
Location: Shropshire

Postby Ean » 26th Mar 08, 22:58

It just seems odd that, if that were the reason, the 4/4 bit is actually rhythmically the most complicated bit of the song... :?

Yep, the studio was full of tape machines with huge loops of tape threaded around the room. I don't know if you've seen it? But the programme they refer to in the Wikipedia entry - Classic Albums: The Dark Side Of The Moon, is excellent as it goes into detail about the whole process, stripping down tracks with the original engineers.

It shows up on BBC4 now and again - and I've seen it on BBC2.

The Motörheid and Nirvana ones are pretty good too.
Ean Ü

"I have to go along with all this reclusive genius stuff... she's going to be very upset when she finds out I'm a reclusive wanker."

WH THEMED WH EMOTiCONS? MAiS OUi!!
User avatar
Ean
 
Posts: 3084
Joined: 10th Feb 06, 15:44
Location: Just next to my confuser


Return to The Cloakroom

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests