Motley Crue - Saints Of Los Angelas (My Review)
Before having listened to this, I will say that this band spent many years as my favorite band of all-time. The Wildhearts knocked them out of that throne pretty effortlessly. Since then they've gradually slipped down one notch at a time until now I can't honestly say I like any of their albums as a whole, other than their first one, Too Fast For Love which will always be a classic for me. Their most recent album, New Tattoo, was almost totally useless to me and the miscellaneous tracks that've been released since then (If I Die Tomorrow, Sick Love Song) are just okay for me.
Now, I've heard the first single from this album, Saints of Los Angelas, and it was better than anything I've heard from them in at least a decade. It wasn't amazing, but it was good enough to think that maybe this album would be something I actually care about. Then I listened to the preview clips of the rest on Amazon and wasn't impressed at all. Naturally there wasn't much I could tell, by I'm going into this expecting it to be mostly just okay with brilliant moments slightly outnumbered by the shit moments.
01 - LAMF
This is a short track. Sounds like mostly soud effects and stuff... and Motley album-opener similar to the ones at the beginning of Shout and Feelgood. It was okay. I expected it to be silly, but they pulled off.
02 - Face Down In The Dirt
"It's a dirty job but someone's gotta do it" repeats a couple of times, kind of whispered/grumbled, over a bassline... gradual built up and then crash into the full band riffing. Good energy. So far I like it except for Vince's pronunciation of "dirty"... sound more like "ditty". Anyway... good riff. Feels like they're into it. "I'd rather be dead, yeah I'd rather be dead. I'd rather be face down in the dirt with a bullet in my head". Good chorus. I liked that. Pretty standard bridge... different riff then a guitar solo... then back into the pre-chorus and then a breakdown chorus chorus and a buildup into a last couple of choruses... with the last one having an AC/DC-esque chanting of "It's a dirty job but someone's gotta do it" in the background.
All in all, this was a rocker for sure. There were a couple of spots where the lyrics, at first, seemed a little silly... where he talks about not wanting to go to school and whatnot, but I'm now feeling like he's not talking about himself so much as speaking sarcastically from the point of view of someone else... probably just the youth of America in general. Looking at it that way, the song is probably a solid 7.5. Lots of energy and momentum... feels like rock 'n' roll to me, but it didn't make me feel like I was in 1986 again... and not a trace of "alternative" to be found.
03 - What's It Gonna Take
This one's got a bouncier and groovier beat. Lyrically, the song seems to be about making it in the music business. "What's it gonna take to make it? I'll do anything but fake it. What's it gonna take to make it here." Not bad so far. Much calmer than the first track though. Sadly I find that my advance copy of this is an edited version with the bad words blanked out. Yeah, so this is catchy... smells a little sad/pathetic with the lyrical theme being what it is... "wahh... we're not popular"... but it's got a good beat and I can tap my foot (the good one) to it. Walking out with the typical repeating chorus... here come the female backup singers, which takes me back to the Girls Girls Girls days.... but still without feeling retro to me.
This isn't really a song that's gonna kick anyone's ass, but it'll likely get stuck in some heads along the way. Still very solid as far as the writing and perfomance go. I'm gonna give this one a 7.
04 - Down At The Whiskey
Started out sounded bigger and badder but the super catchy melody kicks in for the verse. All in a major key. I'm hearing some of their punk roots showing through, which is good. The song seems to be a looking back fondly at days of youth. The chorus goes back into a bluesy kind of riff... then the bridge, just a short guitar solo. Then back into the chorus.
Two pop-rock songs in a row now. This is okay, but it's not what I need from this band right now. My ass is feeling less kicked with every song... at least so far. This one gets a 5 and the album gets a stern warning to get its shit together.
05 - Saints Of Los Angelas
Ahhh... this one. Okay then.
Starts off with a tricky arpeggiated bass riff... soft and slow... with someone whispering something, I think something to do with religion, in the background. Also lots of sound effects and maybe some organ. Here comes the riff that could be a Shout at the Devil outtake. There's a pretty cool chord change in the middle of the verse... not a standard one at all... I like that. Into the pre=chorus... another key change with kind of creepy background vocals kind of droning along. Now the chorus... "We are, we are the saint, we signed out life away" Why oh why couldn't that have said "lives" instead of "life" there? That would've made a disproportionately big difference to me. Anyway... out of the chorus, back into the riff, back into the verse... same thing as before. This one is definitely more rock than the last two. This is what the whole album should be. Into a standard guitar solo... and then into a guilding kind of thing that does a cool stumble right before the chorus. Now repeat the chorus and out...
This is definitely a good track. It would stand up well right next to their other big ones, Live Wire, Shout At The Devil, Wild Side, Girls Girls Girls, Kickstart My Heart. I'll give it an 8.
06 - Motherfucker Of The Year
Starts out with some noise and then into the riff. Into this verse... everything is lower and crunchier. Melody and lyrics are darker... trying to be menacing. Pre-chorus gets a little more friendly... but still not totally goofy. Now the chorus. Pretty cool. It bounces back and forth between the band singing in harmony and Vince coming in with every other line. Another solo... another chorus and little outro-jamming and... done.
This is something this band have been playing around with for the last couple of albums, trying to come across as dark and threatening. It doesn't really do the trick for me specifically. I'll give this one a 5.5, just because it feels like they're trying too hard to be something they're not. Be dirty and sleazy and nasty and ugly, but don't try to make anyone afraid of you. In world full of Sevendusts and System Of A Downs and Disturbeds, you're not gonna corner the heavy and intimidating market.
07 - The Animal In Me
This one's slower... not quite a ballad. Ugh... "we were slowly diggin' innnnnnnnnnn", the lovers that've beennnnnnnnn". Totally stretching out the wrong part of the word, Vince. Very pretty melody for the chorus.... musically it's big and strong. Cool moment just after the chorus with the background vocals. Same deal for the second verse, only with a little more guitar stuff... a little heavier. Second chorus, same thing... guitar solo... then a broken down chorus. Nothing but drums and bass and distortion vocals. Then back into the chorus... there's something weird in the timing of the chorus that's putting me off... at the end when he says "the animal in me" the music is in the middle of kind of a weirdly timed climbing chord progression and it feel like Vince doesn't quite know where to put some of the words.
Mid-tempo. Almost a slow song. It was good except for those vocal spots I pointed out. I'll say 6.5 on this one.
08 - Welcome To The Machine
This is the album's "punk" song, clearly. Fast and simple. This reminds me of something that could've been on Generation Swine. He's trying to sound mean here again... meh. This one isn't doing much for me at all, honestly. Vince does his trademark "rrrowwwww!" a couple of times in this one. First I've heard it on this one.
Yep. Not much to say about this one. Fast, trying really hard to sound badass but not really doing it for me. It gets a 4.
09 - Just Another Psycho
Starts off with just a guitar riff, then kicks in with the whole band... then the verse. "I should be committed, for being so twisted, 'cause eh-ver-ee-one knows, I'm just another psycho. I went to the doctuh, it wasn't a shockuh, when he said I should know, I'm just another psycho." Oh god... that's just tacky. Bad bad bad. Musically it's alright, but lyrically it's seriously just a bunch of different ways of saying, "watch out for me because I'm INSAAANNNEEE, booga booga!" C'mon guys. The first half of the pre-chorus "I'm not okay (I'm not okay), the voices in my head always say".... that part was cool... but the rest. Sheesh.
I'm gonna give this a 3, but it would've been lower if the musical side of it had been as bad as the lyrics are. What the fuck? Is Nikki letting Vince write lyrics now?
10 - Chicks = Trouble
(Hitting pause before the song starts) With a title like "Chicks = Trouble" I will be positively shocked if this ends up being a song that I like even a little bit.
Okay... musically, it's okay, as usual. First verse starts out being a list of expensive things to do "Rolls Royce shopping, vicodin popping..." I guess he's talking about some woman blowing his money. Here's a pretty good line from the prechorus, "I really shouldn't say it, but truth be told, I really thought that pussy was gold". But then the chorus... yeah, it's pretty much what one would expect. He literally says "Chicks equal trouble" a bunch of times. Jesus... and now, on top of the ridiculous theme, this is the first one sounds like it could've come from some lesser-than-Motley-Crue band in 1988.
It gets a 3.5 from me. Silly lyrics, but only in the chorus. Music was okay, but ultimately this is exactly what the haters out of there expect from this band, and it pisses me off that this is pretty much stereotypical hair-metal. Dammit, guys... you're supposed to proving people wrong.
11 - This Ain't A Love Song
Okay... this one starts out a little better. It's got some balls under it... punchy riff in the verse and distortion vocals. Into the chorus, "This ain't a love song, it's just a fuck song." Not bad... not great. Mostly just a song about meaningless sex.
This is mostly just a standard Crue song. It doesn't stand out for me, but there's nothing particularly embarrassing about it, so I'll give it a 5.
12 - White Trash Circus
Swing beat. Ugly and dirty and guitar riff. First verse, "Well I opened up the bottle and I fell out of bed. I couldn't find the floor until it hit me in the head". I ike that line a lot. This one's okay... keeps up its attitude throughout the chorus and into the second verse. Some silly lyrics here and there, of course...
This one was big and kicked some ass. Lyrically it was just a lot of "we're so bad and we don't care", which ended up knocking it down a notch or two, just because it's such a common theme for them. Some great musical moments though. I'll give it a 6.5.
13 - Goin' Out Swingin'
Well, let's see if this one lives up to its title.
It's got some tempo, but not in a punk way. End of the first line he hits a weird note... apparently on purpose. Letting it slide, letting it slide, moving on. Okay. The chorus was good. Nothing stupid it at all. Same stuff for the next verse and chorus. The bridge is kind of a reboot, starting at the intro again and then jumping right back into the chorus. Then into a long frantic jam-session/guitar solo... and fading. And done.
They did manage to pick it back up by the end of the album. This wasn't as good as tracks 2 and 5... or even 3 and 4... but it's better than the majority of the rest. I'll give it a 7.
Okay... so overall, this wasn't a terrible album, but it's a long way from being a great album, even as far as this band is concerned. No songs that I would call "really good"... four or five that I would call "good" at least two that I would call "really bad"... and the rest are just kind of there.
Naturally it'll take a few more listens to really get the hang of it, but going by first impressions I'd rank this one among the other albums as follows:
1. Too Fast For Love
2. Generation Swine
3. Shout At The Devil
4. Doctor Feelgood
5. Girls, Girls, Girls
6. Saints Of Los Angelas
7. Theatre Of Pain
8. New Tattoo
(I don't include the self-title album because I just can't really think of it as Motley Crue, not only because there's a different singer but because it's such a big stylistic departure)
For me, this is a band that's always had a bit of an identity crisis, always being too affected by what is going on in music at that current moment. To me, they started out super-strong and super-honest and gradually fell into a cycle of going back and forth between trying too hard to fit in with the scene and trying too hard to be relevant. This album is clearly an effort to come back with a big splash... and they do rock very hard for a moment or three... and while it's not a retro-80's album like New Tatto, they didn't really bring anything new or particularly interesting like they did with TFFL and Swine. Basically, I think they were thinking too hard about what people would think of it and ended up setting a lot of limits for themselves on what they could do. They did well, but only within the limits they set for themselves.
All in all, I'll give this album a big fat 7, hoping that maybe it'll do well enough to give them a little confidence, and with that artistic leverage, to stretch their legs and be a little more honest with themselves next time, if there is a next time.
Now, I've heard the first single from this album, Saints of Los Angelas, and it was better than anything I've heard from them in at least a decade. It wasn't amazing, but it was good enough to think that maybe this album would be something I actually care about. Then I listened to the preview clips of the rest on Amazon and wasn't impressed at all. Naturally there wasn't much I could tell, by I'm going into this expecting it to be mostly just okay with brilliant moments slightly outnumbered by the shit moments.
01 - LAMF
This is a short track. Sounds like mostly soud effects and stuff... and Motley album-opener similar to the ones at the beginning of Shout and Feelgood. It was okay. I expected it to be silly, but they pulled off.
02 - Face Down In The Dirt
"It's a dirty job but someone's gotta do it" repeats a couple of times, kind of whispered/grumbled, over a bassline... gradual built up and then crash into the full band riffing. Good energy. So far I like it except for Vince's pronunciation of "dirty"... sound more like "ditty". Anyway... good riff. Feels like they're into it. "I'd rather be dead, yeah I'd rather be dead. I'd rather be face down in the dirt with a bullet in my head". Good chorus. I liked that. Pretty standard bridge... different riff then a guitar solo... then back into the pre-chorus and then a breakdown chorus chorus and a buildup into a last couple of choruses... with the last one having an AC/DC-esque chanting of "It's a dirty job but someone's gotta do it" in the background.
All in all, this was a rocker for sure. There were a couple of spots where the lyrics, at first, seemed a little silly... where he talks about not wanting to go to school and whatnot, but I'm now feeling like he's not talking about himself so much as speaking sarcastically from the point of view of someone else... probably just the youth of America in general. Looking at it that way, the song is probably a solid 7.5. Lots of energy and momentum... feels like rock 'n' roll to me, but it didn't make me feel like I was in 1986 again... and not a trace of "alternative" to be found.
03 - What's It Gonna Take
This one's got a bouncier and groovier beat. Lyrically, the song seems to be about making it in the music business. "What's it gonna take to make it? I'll do anything but fake it. What's it gonna take to make it here." Not bad so far. Much calmer than the first track though. Sadly I find that my advance copy of this is an edited version with the bad words blanked out. Yeah, so this is catchy... smells a little sad/pathetic with the lyrical theme being what it is... "wahh... we're not popular"... but it's got a good beat and I can tap my foot (the good one) to it. Walking out with the typical repeating chorus... here come the female backup singers, which takes me back to the Girls Girls Girls days.... but still without feeling retro to me.
This isn't really a song that's gonna kick anyone's ass, but it'll likely get stuck in some heads along the way. Still very solid as far as the writing and perfomance go. I'm gonna give this one a 7.
04 - Down At The Whiskey
Started out sounded bigger and badder but the super catchy melody kicks in for the verse. All in a major key. I'm hearing some of their punk roots showing through, which is good. The song seems to be a looking back fondly at days of youth. The chorus goes back into a bluesy kind of riff... then the bridge, just a short guitar solo. Then back into the chorus.
Two pop-rock songs in a row now. This is okay, but it's not what I need from this band right now. My ass is feeling less kicked with every song... at least so far. This one gets a 5 and the album gets a stern warning to get its shit together.
05 - Saints Of Los Angelas
Ahhh... this one. Okay then.
Starts off with a tricky arpeggiated bass riff... soft and slow... with someone whispering something, I think something to do with religion, in the background. Also lots of sound effects and maybe some organ. Here comes the riff that could be a Shout at the Devil outtake. There's a pretty cool chord change in the middle of the verse... not a standard one at all... I like that. Into the pre=chorus... another key change with kind of creepy background vocals kind of droning along. Now the chorus... "We are, we are the saint, we signed out life away" Why oh why couldn't that have said "lives" instead of "life" there? That would've made a disproportionately big difference to me. Anyway... out of the chorus, back into the riff, back into the verse... same thing as before. This one is definitely more rock than the last two. This is what the whole album should be. Into a standard guitar solo... and then into a guilding kind of thing that does a cool stumble right before the chorus. Now repeat the chorus and out...
This is definitely a good track. It would stand up well right next to their other big ones, Live Wire, Shout At The Devil, Wild Side, Girls Girls Girls, Kickstart My Heart. I'll give it an 8.
06 - Motherfucker Of The Year
Starts out with some noise and then into the riff. Into this verse... everything is lower and crunchier. Melody and lyrics are darker... trying to be menacing. Pre-chorus gets a little more friendly... but still not totally goofy. Now the chorus. Pretty cool. It bounces back and forth between the band singing in harmony and Vince coming in with every other line. Another solo... another chorus and little outro-jamming and... done.
This is something this band have been playing around with for the last couple of albums, trying to come across as dark and threatening. It doesn't really do the trick for me specifically. I'll give this one a 5.5, just because it feels like they're trying too hard to be something they're not. Be dirty and sleazy and nasty and ugly, but don't try to make anyone afraid of you. In world full of Sevendusts and System Of A Downs and Disturbeds, you're not gonna corner the heavy and intimidating market.
07 - The Animal In Me
This one's slower... not quite a ballad. Ugh... "we were slowly diggin' innnnnnnnnnn", the lovers that've beennnnnnnnn". Totally stretching out the wrong part of the word, Vince. Very pretty melody for the chorus.... musically it's big and strong. Cool moment just after the chorus with the background vocals. Same deal for the second verse, only with a little more guitar stuff... a little heavier. Second chorus, same thing... guitar solo... then a broken down chorus. Nothing but drums and bass and distortion vocals. Then back into the chorus... there's something weird in the timing of the chorus that's putting me off... at the end when he says "the animal in me" the music is in the middle of kind of a weirdly timed climbing chord progression and it feel like Vince doesn't quite know where to put some of the words.
Mid-tempo. Almost a slow song. It was good except for those vocal spots I pointed out. I'll say 6.5 on this one.
08 - Welcome To The Machine
This is the album's "punk" song, clearly. Fast and simple. This reminds me of something that could've been on Generation Swine. He's trying to sound mean here again... meh. This one isn't doing much for me at all, honestly. Vince does his trademark "rrrowwwww!" a couple of times in this one. First I've heard it on this one.
Yep. Not much to say about this one. Fast, trying really hard to sound badass but not really doing it for me. It gets a 4.
09 - Just Another Psycho
Starts off with just a guitar riff, then kicks in with the whole band... then the verse. "I should be committed, for being so twisted, 'cause eh-ver-ee-one knows, I'm just another psycho. I went to the doctuh, it wasn't a shockuh, when he said I should know, I'm just another psycho." Oh god... that's just tacky. Bad bad bad. Musically it's alright, but lyrically it's seriously just a bunch of different ways of saying, "watch out for me because I'm INSAAANNNEEE, booga booga!" C'mon guys. The first half of the pre-chorus "I'm not okay (I'm not okay), the voices in my head always say".... that part was cool... but the rest. Sheesh.
I'm gonna give this a 3, but it would've been lower if the musical side of it had been as bad as the lyrics are. What the fuck? Is Nikki letting Vince write lyrics now?
10 - Chicks = Trouble
(Hitting pause before the song starts) With a title like "Chicks = Trouble" I will be positively shocked if this ends up being a song that I like even a little bit.
Okay... musically, it's okay, as usual. First verse starts out being a list of expensive things to do "Rolls Royce shopping, vicodin popping..." I guess he's talking about some woman blowing his money. Here's a pretty good line from the prechorus, "I really shouldn't say it, but truth be told, I really thought that pussy was gold". But then the chorus... yeah, it's pretty much what one would expect. He literally says "Chicks equal trouble" a bunch of times. Jesus... and now, on top of the ridiculous theme, this is the first one sounds like it could've come from some lesser-than-Motley-Crue band in 1988.
It gets a 3.5 from me. Silly lyrics, but only in the chorus. Music was okay, but ultimately this is exactly what the haters out of there expect from this band, and it pisses me off that this is pretty much stereotypical hair-metal. Dammit, guys... you're supposed to proving people wrong.
11 - This Ain't A Love Song
Okay... this one starts out a little better. It's got some balls under it... punchy riff in the verse and distortion vocals. Into the chorus, "This ain't a love song, it's just a fuck song." Not bad... not great. Mostly just a song about meaningless sex.
This is mostly just a standard Crue song. It doesn't stand out for me, but there's nothing particularly embarrassing about it, so I'll give it a 5.
12 - White Trash Circus
Swing beat. Ugly and dirty and guitar riff. First verse, "Well I opened up the bottle and I fell out of bed. I couldn't find the floor until it hit me in the head". I ike that line a lot. This one's okay... keeps up its attitude throughout the chorus and into the second verse. Some silly lyrics here and there, of course...
This one was big and kicked some ass. Lyrically it was just a lot of "we're so bad and we don't care", which ended up knocking it down a notch or two, just because it's such a common theme for them. Some great musical moments though. I'll give it a 6.5.
13 - Goin' Out Swingin'
Well, let's see if this one lives up to its title.
It's got some tempo, but not in a punk way. End of the first line he hits a weird note... apparently on purpose. Letting it slide, letting it slide, moving on. Okay. The chorus was good. Nothing stupid it at all. Same stuff for the next verse and chorus. The bridge is kind of a reboot, starting at the intro again and then jumping right back into the chorus. Then into a long frantic jam-session/guitar solo... and fading. And done.
They did manage to pick it back up by the end of the album. This wasn't as good as tracks 2 and 5... or even 3 and 4... but it's better than the majority of the rest. I'll give it a 7.
Okay... so overall, this wasn't a terrible album, but it's a long way from being a great album, even as far as this band is concerned. No songs that I would call "really good"... four or five that I would call "good" at least two that I would call "really bad"... and the rest are just kind of there.
Naturally it'll take a few more listens to really get the hang of it, but going by first impressions I'd rank this one among the other albums as follows:
1. Too Fast For Love
2. Generation Swine
3. Shout At The Devil
4. Doctor Feelgood
5. Girls, Girls, Girls
6. Saints Of Los Angelas
7. Theatre Of Pain
8. New Tattoo
(I don't include the self-title album because I just can't really think of it as Motley Crue, not only because there's a different singer but because it's such a big stylistic departure)
For me, this is a band that's always had a bit of an identity crisis, always being too affected by what is going on in music at that current moment. To me, they started out super-strong and super-honest and gradually fell into a cycle of going back and forth between trying too hard to fit in with the scene and trying too hard to be relevant. This album is clearly an effort to come back with a big splash... and they do rock very hard for a moment or three... and while it's not a retro-80's album like New Tatto, they didn't really bring anything new or particularly interesting like they did with TFFL and Swine. Basically, I think they were thinking too hard about what people would think of it and ended up setting a lot of limits for themselves on what they could do. They did well, but only within the limits they set for themselves.
All in all, I'll give this album a big fat 7, hoping that maybe it'll do well enough to give them a little confidence, and with that artistic leverage, to stretch their legs and be a little more honest with themselves next time, if there is a next time.