Page 1 of 1
Nickelback

Posted:
20th Jun 06, 11:44
by Marc
Shit hot or just shit?
Interesting one this is, I have always 'liked' their music, wouldn't say I was mad on it etc but saw them live and they were simply awesome, working well off of the crowd etc...
Speaking to quite a few 'rock' heads they say they are a bunch of namby pamby rockers who are not very good. Granted none have seen this lot live though. Does live music really show what a band is about rather than the album work?
I will say something, they did one thing I have never seen done live before.... The lead singer sang his own backing vocals, whilst singing the main track, uses two mic's one for backing that gives the echo's and one for the main part, so when the echo comes across he is singing into the main mic and re-producing the song as a whole was pretty cool seeing that happen live.

Posted:
21st Jun 06, 02:47
by weebleboy
I'd say they're pretty good, but they get a dodgy rep for being soft amongst the rock fans cos they only ever seem to release ballads since Silver side up, despite having some damn good songs. They're more likely to have a middle of the road Bon Jovi style following that the 'true rockers' or owt like that cos they seem to be generally looked down upon amongst the people who take their own musical opinions too seriously.
I like them, and after checking out their live DVD I regret missing them last time they toured.

Posted:
24th Jun 06, 20:08
by gayl
I saw them support Bon Jovi at Hampden and thought they were pretty boring, to be honest. So my vote's for shit!

Posted:
2nd Jul 06, 19:32
by someone else
The problem with Nickelback is the total lack of joy or humour in their music, both live and on record.

Posted:
3rd Jul 06, 20:30
by Glen666
Absolutely bore me to tears. No excitement or enthusiasm at all.

Posted:
5th Jul 06, 10:16
by Zo
Saw them upporting bon jovi a month or so back.
Have to say they completely bored me.
Didn't really mind their music before that, but now I want to run screaming every time I hear them!
Sorry!

Posted:
6th Jul 06, 04:11
by bennympls
Generic, leftover floating shite that Cobain left in the toilet. He didnt even bother to flush it before he pulled the trigger

Posted:
12th Jul 06, 15:19
by Bang!
Utter load of crap tbh, agree with the chap above that they are totally generic, un-inspired, boring and frankly very middle-of-the-road :S

Posted:
21st Apr 07, 02:21
by Trudi

Posted:
21st Apr 07, 06:06
by seventieslord
weebleboy wrote: they seem to be generally looked down upon amongst the people who take their own musical opinions too seriously.
Truer words haven't been spoken for days.
Nickelback are nowhere near as good as their screaming legions of teenage girls in Canda would have you believe, and they are nowhere near as bad as The Rock Snobs will accuse them of being.
I have all their albums, I follwed them from the start. Their beginnings were humble. They rocked, and had great indie cred. Nothing spectacular, but some definite canadian charm and spunk. They have gone downhill lately, but not as much as some may say. Their radio garbage is what drives most peoples' opinions of them, so it doesn't surprise me.
In the same day I could be talking to some schmuch and say "what?? Nickelback is your favourite band? Do you get out at all??" and then defend them to some HMV employee who swears they're a shitty mass produced sales machine designed to appease the masses.
So I voted they're OK.

Posted:
21st Apr 07, 11:23
by Zo
Trudi - that link is pure GENIUS!!!

Posted:
21st Apr 07, 12:03
by pete
i'd say shit but oh lord help me i liked that
so bad or too bad record or whatever it was called

Posted:
21st Apr 07, 16:14
by blackdeathcrew
Shit in my opinion

Posted:
23rd Apr 07, 19:41
by Workyticket
The thing with Nickelback for me is, every time I hear them on the radio my thought process goes this exact way:
'OH! crunchy guitars!'...
...'Hm, that's not a bad melody there'...
...'OK, I'm sure it's all going to kick off any time now'...
...'Any time'...
...' '...
...'Shit, this is dull. Must be Nickelback'.
I don't hate Nickelback; I just hate their seemingly superhuman ability to take loud guitars and a good melody, and do absolutely fucking nothing interesting with it.