I thought you all might like to read this. It's a piece I just wrote for the BBC.
Hi BBC!
I was on your Have Your Say radio show again today - thank you for inviting me back - and once again, we touched on a drastic cultural difference between current-day American society and British culture. American culture is nothing like what you Brits see, so I thought I'd type out how things really are over here for you. Since I get a different Producer each time I'm on your show, I have to explain the differences each time. This is meant as a reference, and hopefully, it'll come in handy for you.
Your British - and I assume European - culture is a very coherent one. You have uniformity in how things are done, who people turn to for news or entertainment, and you tend to have collective opinions as far as I can tell. One example of this was my discussion with today's producer when she thought that all young people think and act the same way and have the same views and opinions as each other. Whether this is true on your street level or not, this is what's visible to at least the producer and, I assume, the BBC as a whole. You have mainstream outlets for old school (physical) media that apparently serve the population as a whole, examples being newspapers, magazines, and I believe old electronic media (radio and TV). Likewise, it's my undertsanding compact discs still sell for music. (Do people there still go to physical movie theaters there? Do you still have those?)
In contrast, American culture is very niche. We are digitally-based thanks to the internet which means compared to you, we are very fragmented as a society. The repercussions of this are far-reaching. Unlike your culture, we have no "mainstream" outlets. While you visually see that we do, on the street, you'd see we don't. We stopped buying compact discs in th early- and middle- 1990s. We haven't read magazines since the earliest 1990s. We don't read books, either. Any books we do read are digital files read on a tech device. We don't watch network TV (check the numbers if you don't believe me). We stopped going to movie theaters (again, check the numbers), which have closed en masse as they struggle to survive like the TV networks and old paradigm music industry. Speaking of music industry, no musician wants anything to do with the organizations once called "major record labels". Bands run the other way if one approaches. Bands here don't have one specific business model they follow; they're free to run their band and do anything they want. The make their music, they own all their rights, they distribute their own music, and the only professional help they're looking for is a good manager who believes in them. This is very different from your society. We give music away free, we take donations or put up donation boxes, and we live off live shows and band merchandise. This freedom from business people means bands can be as creative as they want with their business. As for the people's entertainment, it's all online. We file-share and file-swap to find new bands and music. Maybe we like their music; maybe we don't. Even the old school network shows people DO want to watch are DOWNLOADED off the web. The TV networks get more eyeballs online than on TV. Movies are downloaded, too. Young people and old alike are swollowed in the happy world of digital tech. The video game Guitar God (I think that's what it's called) is our current pop culture superstar. Any band on there is a huge hit -- and they're all "OLD" - pre-1993. (That's because everything after 1993 stinks.) As for news and information, once again, it's all online. Yahoo news is a big one. (I like flipping through yours, personally.) News and information is personally selected by interest; there's no monstrous "major player" media pushing their wares down people's throats anymore. People select what they like and get their own RSS feeds or whatever. That's an example of the individual niche and fragmented culture we have.
One of our biggest problems here is that there is no way to reach everybody. With no mainstream outlet and everyone in niche fragments, entertainers, advertizers, and others alike have no way to reach the mass public. We don't listen to radio; we have iPods. It has plenty of downfalls - especially if something is very important - but this is what people here like. We cater our lives and our choices to ourselves. If a massive news event happens, it's all word-of-mouth to get it around. MOST things now are spread word-of-mouth. This is a big difference from what you see our society as being through "visible" means (as my producer and I discussed). We aren't like you at all; you just SEE the old media - which has nothing to do with what it's really like here - and assume they are an accurate reflection of our society. It's not. They're out of touch, they are desperate for their own survival, and they still PRETEND people care. Look at the numbers of how many people DIDN'T watch the Oscars (or the Grammy's or the Superbowl or ...). Such events pretend to still be relevant, but they're not. No one cares. What you see is an illusion that is not reality.
Again, this letter is meant for your reference to explain our cultural differences. I hate to sound awkward on your show when something that sounds so standard to you (and the rest of the world) gets an answer of, "That doesn't translate culturally - so let's go with your culture."
Best wishes and thanks again for having me on your show.
Monica Ice
Comments welcome.