earthvs wrote:To my mind he was a bit of a buffoon with too much time and money on his hands. Let's face it, it wouldn't take a political genius with supernatural powers of persuasion to convince most slack-jawed Americans that waving a gun about in public for their own "protection" was a terrific idea. You might argue that if he hadn't been so pro-firearms that many youngsters might not have lost their lives, but that is a very tenuous argument - akin, in my mind, to blaming Marilyn Manson for some kid's suicide/murder spree just because he had the guy's t-shirt on and a few of his CDs - Guns don't kill people. People kill people.
I don't buy this really.
I certainly agree that its ridiculous to blame music such as Marilyn Manson, Dr Dre etc. or indeed games like GTA & Manhunt for people killing each other but I don't think its quite the same thing as actively campaigning for deadly weapons to be readily available in the name of 'safety'. Now, I'm not suggesting that you're pro-guns as you clearly haven't said so at all, I'm just saying that its somewhat disingenuous to draw a parallel between the promotion of guns, which may not in themselves kill people but make it a damn sight easier to do so, & the influence of 'art' which is at the very worst, morally dubious.
Of course people should ultimately bear responsibility for their actions but there are a hell of a lot of irresponsible people out there so as far as I'm concerned, the harder it is to get hold of guns the better.
I think Eddie sums it up best...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P1m65v8QI3Aearthvs wrote:From what i've seen in the past - and more as a direct result of the "Right to Bear Arms" part of their Constitution - Heston's attitude towards guns wasn't too far to the right of many other Republican Americans. But because they are not public faces (or the head of the NRA), nobody pays any attention to them or gives their opinions a platform.
I heard that this amendment was actually the result of a trade-off between several opposing factions of the founding fathers. The pro-hunting lobby wanted the right to hang the heads of hunted bears on the walls of their lodges while the animal rights lobby wanted a ban on such barbaric practices. Thankfully, the Brotherhood of Taxidermists was able to broker a satisfactory deal in which the citizens of the newly formed union would have the right to "Bear arms", but the bears' heads remained mercifully outlawed.
*ahem*
Allegedly...
earthvs wrote:Basically, I don't think he was a bad guy per se. Humans are all - without exception - fundamentally flawed. Some more than others, but nobody is mercifully free of at least one episode of cuntish behaviour, I am certain.
As a fan of Charlton Heston the Actor, rather than Charlton Heston the Deranged Republican, I think that the guy could be cut some slack, after all, we see other celebrities behaving like arseholes to a greater or lesser degree than Heston, but because they're not necessarily advocating carrying firearms or claiming a "right" under some constitutional clause that offends Left-wing sensibilities, they are left to carry on without having the magnificent Michael Moore following them around trying to make them look like bigger twats than they do already.
I presume your thesis on the fundamentally flawed human being extends to - and I quote - "that twat Pete Docherty." [sic] & his fans who "think they have to like an artist just because all their mates do." Incidentally, I'm curious as to which one of this hypothetical peer group liked Pete first & who
they were copying from in the first place...

Anyway, to paraphrase your good self, I have no problem separating the man & his art from the deed/belief - I'm a fan of Pete Doherty the musician & songwriter rather than Pete Doherty the junkie. Or "twat" as you put it.
I'm also aware that John Lennon was a raging misogynist & a smackhead. I've heard conflicting evidence on the IRA thing & the Commie accusations were more McCarthy-esque FBI paranoia than anything concrete but its fairly safe to say he was quite probably a bit of a nasty cunt regardless.
I don't agree that the left has any protected status as you seem to be suggesting. I get all kinds of shit both on the net & in plain old Yorkshire boozers for being a lefty-liberal despite 'lefty' & 'liberal' being 2 very different things as I can't help but point out. In about 70% of the UK press its open season on liberals (or the left - neither I nor they are sure which they mean) who are apparently the cause of all terrorism, crime & deviant behaviour the world over. But... I'm tired.
I will say however that much as I find Michael Moore's films entertaining & informative (to a certain extent anyway) I felt very uncomfortable watching the 'interview' with Charlton Heston. I don't agree with the late Chuck's politics but neither do I like seeing an elderly man being bullied on camera.
Goodnight & good luck.
"You say that now... but how are you at canasta?!"