BEST WiLDHEARTS LiNE UP?

[RDP]

I agree with others in that ritch, ginger, danny, cj were the best. However, with danny's 'problems', it didn't seem to ever work and scott is a pillar.

[Damian]

Lots of amazing people have meant that despite all the band's problems, they've managed to keep going for so long. So all of them. But the current line-up is fantastic, never does a bad show and have meant that for some time now, everyone talks about the music rather than the soap opera. Which is brilliant.

They're all brilliant, except perhaps that singer, whatever he's called.

(joke)

[Sarc]

They're all brilliant, except perhaps that singer, whatever he's called.

(joke)

Y'mean the red headed wonder that was Viv Stanshall *wonders how many people will know who im on about without googleing it)

[beerofthedark]

I've seen almost every line-up since the Full Roar days (didn't see Devin Townshend or Mark Keds), and I've seen some awesome gigs from each of them. But the Astoria gig last December was close to the best I'ver ever seen them play. And as has been said elsewhere in this thread, Scott brings some much needed stability to the group. So, for those reasons i think we are witnessing the best line-up right now.

[lob]

They're all brilliant, except perhaps that singer, whatever he's called.

(joke)

Y'mean the red headed wonder that was Viv Stanshall *wonders how many people will know who im on about without googleing it)

The original "Ginger Geezer"

(also the name of a pretty good biography of one of Rock's true eccentrics RIP)

[bettylorux]

Ginger,Danny, CJ and Rich for me.

Rich is like a steady rock

[stuff]

Ginger, CJ, Joolz and Pat... the first time is always the best time... or so I'm led to belive

[Sarc]

They're all brilliant, except perhaps that singer, whatever he's called.

(joke)

Y'mean the red headed wonder that was Viv Stanshall *wonders how many people will know who im on about without googleing it)

The original "Ginger Geezer"

(also the name of a pretty good biography of one of Rock's true eccentrics RIP)

He's right y'know and I read the book through in one sitting, fucking loved it, such a shame how he kharked it.

[Ean]

...didn't see... Mark Keds

I don't think the band saw that much of him?!

[blundellfamily]

Don't forget that Keds wrote Too Much Kissing, and Homophobic Asshole, two of the greatest songs in the whole world ever. With more time, could it have worked out? Would the world be a different place?

Where is Keds now? Music or "working for a living"?

[vickyp]

Where is Keds now? Music or "working for a living"?

From what I can gather: he went overseas for a few years, wrote a song for the Libertines, went to rehab, formed a band, formed another one, took up dj-ing. This is what the internet tells me anyway.
Last time I saw him was in a stairwell at Newcastle Students Union in about 1998 so he could be on the moon (with steve) for all I know.

[firedup]

Yes.

[vanrad]

Now this a line-up I never saw........

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJLHJV6FZPs

[Sarc]

Shame they lost the horn section but at least Ginge has improved his dress sense somewhat

[wildsam6o]

Now this a line-up I never saw........

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJLHJV6FZPs

hahaha, same here! shame that! nothing like abit o bass